ࡱ> KVL` nbjbjss U3K8&$ VVlllZ$h fCO@CllX   |8ll   AlJ sYn0a,x x x t #CC^   Date 30th January 2009 Mr Richard Home General Manager Strategic Analysis and Development Branch Australian Competition and Consumer Commission GPO Box 520 MELBOURNE VIC 3001 Email: richard.home@accc.gov.au digitalradio@accc.gov.au Dear Mr Home, DIGITAL RADIO: ACCESS UNDERTAKINGS, DRAFT DECISION I write on behalf of 3RPH, the Vision Australia Radio Melbourne metropolitan wide community broadcasting station licensed to address the information needs of people with a print disability (the print handicapped). Under digital radio legislation 3RPH is eligible to access capacity on the digital radio multiplex facilities currently being established. Subject to the determination of appropriate access arrangements, we wish to participate in digital radio and contribute to the diversity of services available, in accordance with the objects of the Broadcast Act. We note that the ԭ has published a draft decision in relation to access undertakings lodged by the digital radio multiplex licensees and that further comment is sought. In reviewing the ԭ draft decision, we are alarmed that the ԭ has not paid proper and full regard to the legitimate role and situation of community broadcasters. The CBAA submission lodged late in 2008 cogently outlined the concerns of this station and has our full support. We are very concerned that key points raised in that submission seem to have been set aside by the ԭ. 3RPH is licensed to broadcast for particular and specific purposes which serve the otherwise unmet needs of people with a print disability. Moreover, there is legislation that requires the station to operate on a not for profit basis. Of course this is an entirely different situation to that of a commercial broadcaster. The special status of community broadcasting as distinct from commercial broadcasting licensees has been recognised to some extent by the reservation of capacity on the digital radio multiplex for specifically community broadcasting purposes. We wish to stress that community broadcasters are sensitive to open ended costs. It is not simply that all broadcasters seeking access are equal and that some lack financial resources. Special treatment is required because - by law - community broadcasters must operate using good governance principles on a not for profit basis. 3RPH has a legislated entitlement to digital radio capacity and its situation is legitimate. Its situation cannot be equated with that of a commercial broadcaster, or of a commercial broadcaster lacking in financial resources. We therefore write to ensure the ԭ is left in no doubt as to the points which need addressing before this station can - in keeping with its governance obligations - access digital radio capacity. There must be a high degree of certainty and clarity about costs. The potential for the costs to be radically altered beyond a margin must be eliminated. Costs incurred by material changes to the equipment and facilities must be eliminated. In particular, we note that introduction of site redundancy has the potential to double costs. Changes of this type and scale must be factored outside of the standard access arrangements. The cost for access should be limited to a pro-rata of the total maximum of 2/9th of overall multiplex costs. Any mechanism that does not give that certainty of cost will mean the station will be faced with open ended costs and is not acceptable. All risk for any unused capacity should be borne only by the potential beneficiaries of that risk, not by not-for-profit non-shareholding Access Seekers. Vision Australia also believes it is critical that consumers are provided with the best possible means to navigate services on their radio. We believe this is achieved by all broadcasters participating in an ensemble wide EPG on a multi-lateral basis. We believe it to be entirely appropriate for the ԭ to be pro-active in this matter for the benefit of consumers. It is not enough for the ԭ to take a narrow view of its role as only ensuring there are commercial opportunities for potential providers of EPG services. In any case we believe this will not be so much a commercial opportunity but rather will take the form of a contract tendered to a third party by the multiplex licensee. At the very minimum the ԭ should require that all broadcasters / access seekers are treated equally on any EPG that is developed for digital radio multiplexes. Finally, we wish you to note that Access Undertaking in its current form and with only the minor adjustments sought by the ԭ in its draft decision will leave 3RPH unable to seek access if it is to act consistently with good governance principles. It is clear therefore that the current undertaking will hinder access. We trust you will take our views into account.  Yours sincerely Stephen Jolley Manager Vision Australia Radio     Vision Australia Radio 454 Glenferrie Rd, Kooyong Vic. 3144 Melbourne RPH 1179 AM 454 Glenferrie Rd, Kooyong Vic. 3144 Ph: 03 9864 9333 Fax: 03 9864 9344 rph.melbourne@visionaustralia.org.au  HYPERLINK "http://www.visionaustralia.org.au" www.visionaustralia.org.au ACN 108 391 831 ABN 67 108 391 831    2 = D !"$%'(*$%譝艂{sosososokckXjh|1Ujh|1Uh|1hnjhnU hKuih hKuihshMjhsUmHnHtH uhKuihMCJH*OJQJaJhKuihMCJOJQJaJ hKuihHb5hKuihM5 hKuih bhKuihHb5B*phhKuihMB*ph hKuihM jhKuih8UmHnHu")9c2 3 j k   $da$gdM dgdMdgd~im h{s hcd$d^a$gdM$dx^a$gdMm$$ & Fdx^`a$gdMm$ $da$gdM !#$&')*ifghikl 9r ($d N(x]^gd|1 $da$gdM%&@Aghijlmn hKuihh:xjhFUhnhW`h|1h0Bh|10Jjh|1U lmn6&P 1h:p|1. A!S"S#n$n% n(b3=;9PNG  IHDRf+ gAMAPLTEٟ pHYs4-}IDATxٽ6`.@\0 \MW^ub-76[ p)B# )-%H§JOɟ^llllllllO7` `g00 IGC<݌\2bye|*bl5*hHjcTaf#Ut=~UN (߆) D.RCƔ{(|@tw7ԛFqB3D=5?, |P%)3̍k v1o@}W\PfCl] CM W>]&Ֆ(]Pf,B)(׫UfpArq$ k?ABڔ bsB)G{4փԗ:61 #dgB Hޗc[fT2VF17 HĘ!hQӐa/C-FD:?*;Бd. a2_ F ƙѵ!A_jqFìub5ThN6580>΀8 _reԇ 3yr6Ѡm nhZQP]u+F)ml]킍ǘ5Xχ2lFdvhwө!3h],a~ ܶ%q0`:g@HO`3^6s}Xq@ru}ӬΙau{P֐րÿK8LG[/{?U6r r FЙ5ֿi+RcCu+eCݒݦg/fFEۻя@+Fa0U|u'33JM^C. mN 4qVҋvIr]$ w}[;=;dE}e\Fsȿ1Z2Lx;y!V_QF?Cv*l6KLˏ0zmhd JLmCzCC`\_CyC+{){'͠|ˈllllllllll'hsKIENDB`DyK www.visionaustralia.org.auyK Fhttp://www.visionaustralia.org.au/g-Dd 0  # Ab,IѺAf,5 n,IѺAfPNG  IHDRh>7sRGB,`IDATx^ U?첃" E! "¢#QA$"AEDdQvade͝vͻoz;|vWWU~d5 hρ4pHL7mmi h6n--C?!m2@[@[@~-Cd h h H[@tmm i83-- m & ~qժ۞]{|8E#7iғG-%,Wi6;ɰdXYH3 hHH4p$Z@Y@G hN/bԧ*)6 Zo #oQ5,۵nWk hHY"g0vq(SBXa}4pY(Ǐo۶C۶m?uW^YXbʗ]vRD;:ٽ%J]V"طo޽{鲩z5jժUp:`Ï߿-' 2Ui2YJ5 m}[+B;vhM&UW_}냮駟0aº5(ӸYӞ={fI 3gX"իc]wlɧ4tYJ&͔/Fd^+N)s)s5ϢW-} M+G{G vh 3\ax|ٳfA9d`4WS )FXMղoɢLgD@JNb]hy}@Ȱڻg3*Bk()}W@5Xٺ tB 2BYE (gH Yͫ M]ǿ·cNp1dNSzbmLoQp.]:wֵfBMz[;ԯ_B n9 YY]g>KP! v5iڵîd= ֆeoU. 6;2g2ۛG_ַj ba{Uף.҅ Fp0py'FfVChD=|VMsO (D Fw'8Fm!%B8 fр׾-JW$qDթK"hQuKޘcM'0NAnzW.wk%c!*b2XR%`&UZ\\d*.-ZL $p8 N3SAĔ84>xrH0 %XѴq"R󏺜Ѥc͉68g1Πu)yz& !m?{zɟ [*큅c;u*QhUqή Rb*4psYt+S YzCd@~a@dY8A8unuy|_۾XH/i#oM͒^\fռQHql? ,t:ݢaJo((\ }QaP'6(3QM{mnIhu}7 |FgPkPŸ4(J#"~]+tUVñ} ^Ff;rrUٰwi1\o'f-lL  ֋l!7BlgS>UfFɫ!h  AKp?|PV k)oGfOj,&YjFH`R|4p$i;Қ$qf_"+ /Z#ڥa*dS9˰h- Ϟud^,,Xt -On,:zDǠlّX?I߅AUǓ]bdft_w@ ֤riXSZ3`$QmZS׵~Hӳ@0?FҚar˻׸d:u*7:J䏼USkNJu?J I- &rDm|PɖF}zAVl')_m䦘M612qRPQCβYC"CX"`fi`=d&Ò::ܢ,p:e-NC6:<\ʤ}vV89_ƌV7'[QW>>5զ?4rğ|j 1{yglH`,?U1[SP-/"Jտ 2$_7+tҾ՗ռTU* 8xvhu0%.ɓ'lPB[Hg8(jPF`THsߞg[g9~4V]+cTF2‚m$Od0dNdq+Ia8Fdendv|2LGfg D㕎DڹJf}Cˮ[/f5dP@Q&"'J($B t EDtpR/9czM<50>w+ǹjŴsbHI\ %HaʥkbO#%|&R Mb4WkVq@)R$F3z46VL'Ɵԕ.>*9U?F $-:5PXЫkh&-7ѽ57)F1Ĺ;'_a^OeID8.ܽ#wqi|SLL`>EG4G1#{nε4-qX6IJ7VBȝ=g)7mkѵ^$^C9FŤEi;)VB|-'Ucf2  a=-«?E4Gb+ .vX}9gáL6_3#@%g\9a"oD`(cFt7. m:O{y7pID0ıj,H d9&8G= 2YbEEs{)^wE^C^۶?&xiHC@s;Vvl˽)[۝D*͏6=RTx؂KQϒTqp`a|8qf~OgM]G=;sΙȾzڲK=^L YQ{vO#i|p=v&eV#F5IU+T/Iw:x9,\еyvvugDݷ/mi !h:N6)u&IK k4+>߆6U爫|oeN4afg`PHB'l|,#׳9tәj2,]:䴫P=/hUV| zڵsÙ&lOlgp,sHP"wPJGQ )rpB;_2$YD ᵍsK @%K|pPM gՒbFS.=ۇekң|5#XY/_YBjáa$n85[lꙟ-H up{W/8%\} b&)|6uV1~[[!k[pbkMDdUɿ@iZ)O0$|WCh3B^ + #X'ċcQ|&8|}W\àv1;/P2U<̄N j#klTRoXk,k\0g~H5 eʪH5$j ЙPAc0c4c8+3 vzU Ö-[CIćYjJCvWO%JT4SeK-Z+:l>Z`>_5Jba |̴VX0RK>k<|"IF' &K@uJRvmW8ǩR̀#Musmꟑ5UpfjZyjpD(tQB ٞ zk GFWQqISüW.rM^+J!mצ cChnB{{ܙN?_czG-awʷCܸ Lு# F+B 8=β?ij!a;Cbc^S6>ѭ +ސkGr쬥RDa2qQlɲR"'in8dHӧI!+y"_đKMbY< ɴ㷱u N9jß?10RǑϱqƉsle>saOMH"YpAs>QB.-s5m;o\SjL;G#4fXi0,Lj޷b wk~(hFT/N+ QS&p$WDŽK[[-m"#n'9vÇNؗ[Z.a"E]jH6@MJߺ"ǎ26V/St /d''⏍ ˨ƜǰGDxꡦFpv1\َ6oȻ"i*g/<4 :5Ow=r\\%nȗ/v\Y06[q[RUvP~+үHY/oP;SHd?8pLD:s b٩chh7Y0؁+|Ѳ.9`2jer|Z][@cymUkt׶Тuu+n۲aW^6k5'mU ꩡ )^Bw|򥎍 ܒӷ1WHrXa"?lE4Тj%b~ۘ 9dX{6A!<図\_ŰEЖZs)l[. L~nZtҬ>0=WC)*M`- v},5lRisg=VG@qL@Y,=g dx~lYP;W5,(%^RAmf"& 1;=a8H4{l!wOΘzUhAt=a)!'TD\\+]^ 2$l%A]W8 % lRI6{oRM\\$|pX3wߧ|18ɓtn&#ΘE@Kn$2A$!4pYdȵM/w+d6!vcܐ_AmzTCKRp*8;h{>udy7K#|nm_D `pmyV e@!oa79J!T(鯫LJz)xv]9s=F-%ߟ /0ۘ+(WJmRc'e w5n+p\V3@8/͇@&=|0#>lcs!\qPY'E@LTk+|W RBAy&_تdPMW+@UH|R8ؑAvRo{ tA@!.n:E:+Az*zJȹBNkq 'ΝہhbuD'ekÜ& ݳpjfRsZEA:4t=2CeʕwY&)Esjg">%3T̈*15<8>)CM׾Fnh H"D|srC [V%ʋ@58D28a·s B'T0nj!:)Aa0}_xwz 0AUC@8 4ݱ[[ h%h8SUU' Ujn]Ҵ bF#pG䒹&e|m3)#:3Gr6a 2Mƭa Ӂo5^m銃*N!"0B꺯9{Yn\"F 1)@ZS% V@ù3789-[h#~$~8*%j+S/(zx$%BG W nɧMZ( (I敖"^gάծz{wYb}PHCʝF?4\ XL0<`-T+PVJ X8/߈/ʵb: (rA 1+\` O]x)RʿBF4 Fwɶhlz0 XWm+"E&k"3}K&ϓd:QRu4@"1LvG&Gwmѵ48d<2viب[DȧۋImʾ؛}%يogߛSV_r/"ڰ>=>7Ұ!h?*4j2*;˥N`"ʜ>qxH|мB_f> ո? '^L C1E3Coj +.1<E2b91_N5ʔXѸmo `2ueʶ 8 vxT2lnh޲v`1 '|0o=Q5U-k,r@09h#` \-ۏA[@ .U0$;.1e,],$*ꐲgL9CXNX+6~l?rnd|}@=|vߡ,[hd$_G i #PA[ /,#/ej 8b>Z}m-s hj8Z@-# h k1V_[ /,#/ej 8b>Z}m-s hj8Z@-# h k1V_[ /,"+IENDB`\@\ 8Normal dx)B*CJOJQJ_HaJmH phsH tH l@l 8 Heading 2$$ Ndhh@&5B*CJ$aJmH phsH DA@D Default Paragraph FontRiR  Table Normal4 l4a (k(No List4@4 |1Header  9r 4 @4 |1Footer  9r 6U@6 |1 Hyperlink >*B*pht#t 8 Table Grid7:V0 dxfO2f MList Paragraph^m$B*CJOJPJQJaJphnn,)9c23  jk     h { s hcd !#$&')*ifghiklo000000000000000000000000000000000000 0 0 0 0 000000000000000@0h00@0h00@0h00@0h00@0@0@0@0@0h0000`Hifgo 08@0@0@0@0 08 JJJM%n lnm"MXl,b$(b3=;98,@f(  b  C "` b  S 2A signatureB S  ?nW(tP t@ _Hlt118176578 _Hlt118176579 _Hlt118177571,,?o@@@--@oU2V2 W2ī X2 Y2D Z2tM[2tL\2L]2$^2_2d`24a2 ĝb2 c2 d2 t $  11iio     #((::rro 8 *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsCity=*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttags PlaceName: *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsStreetB*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagscountry-region9*urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsplace; *urn:schemas-microsoft-com:office:smarttagsaddress (H    !!#$&')*Ahilo  !!#$&')*Ahilo3  !!#$&')*<@hSeeffo  !!#$&')*hioN1 `^`o(() ^`hH. pL^p`LhH. @ ^@ `hH. ^`hH. L^`LhH. ^`hH. ^`hH. PL^P`LhH.N1)|2        MxEA|1Hb5W` b?՜.+,՜.+,< hp  Vision Australia"   Title 8@ _PID_HLINKSA0j#http://www.visionaustralia.org.au/SummaryInformation(CDocumentSummaryInformation8MCompObjq  FMicrosoft Office Word Document MSWordDocWord.Document.89q